By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
pelapakmobil.compelapakmobil.compelapakmobil.com
  • Home
  • World
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Health
  • Technology
  • Contact Us
    • Terms of Use
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
Reading: Saudi Shura Council Member’s Controversial Remarks on Relocating Israel Draws International Reaction
Share
Notification Show More
Aa
pelapakmobil.compelapakmobil.com
Aa
  • Home
    • Home 1
    • Home 2
    • Home 3
    • Home 4
    • Home 5
  • Home
    • Home 1
    • Home 2
    • Home 3
    • Home 4
    • Home 5
  • Home
    • Home 1
    • Home 2
    • Home 3
    • Home 4
    • Home 5
  • Home
  • Home
  • Categories
  • Categories
  • Demos
  • Demos
  • Demos
  • Categories
  • More Foxiz
    • Blog Index
    • Forums
    • Complaint
    • Sitemap
  • Categories
  • Categories
  • More Foxiz
    • Blog Index
    • Forums
    • Complaint
    • Sitemap
  • Bookmarks
  • Bookmarks
  • Bookmarks
  • More Foxiz
    • Sitemap
  • More Foxiz
    • Sitemap
  • More Foxiz
    • Sitemap
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
pelapakmobil.com > Blog > Politics > Saudi Shura Council Member’s Controversial Remarks on Relocating Israel Draws International Reaction
PoliticsWorld

Saudi Shura Council Member’s Controversial Remarks on Relocating Israel Draws International Reaction

Andy
323.8k Views
6 Min Read
SHARE

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — A member of Saudi Arabia’s Shura Council, Yousef bin Trad Al-Saadoun, has sparked global controversy after reportedly suggesting that Israel should be “relocated” to Alaska and later Greenland during discussions addressing regional tensions. The remarks, framed as a response to recent statements by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former U.S. President Donald Trump, have drawn sharp criticism from international observers and raised questions about Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic stance.

The Context of the Remarks

The Shura Council, Saudi Arabia’s formal advisory body, rarely comments on foreign policy matters publicly. However, during a closed-door session this week, Al-Saadoun allegedly criticized Netanyahu’s policies in the occupied Palestinian territories and referenced Trump’s 2020 proposal for a Middle East peace plan, which heavily favored Israeli interests.

In a leaked transcript circulated online, Al-Saadoun reportedly stated: “If the international community insists on supporting Israel’s unjust occupation, perhaps it is time to move Israel itself—first to Alaska, then to Greenland. Let them experience being guests on others’ land.” The comments, though symbolic, were interpreted as a critique of Israel’s settlement expansions and U.S. backing of such policies.

Saudi Arabia’s Official Response

Saudi officials swiftly distanced the government from Al-Saadoun’s remarks, emphasizing that they do not reflect the kingdom’s official position. A Foreign Ministry spokesperson clarified that Saudi Arabia remains committed to the Arab Peace Initiative, which advocates for a two-state solution based on 1967 borders.

Analysts note that the Shura Council holds no legislative power, and its members’ opinions often represent personal viewpoints rather than state policy. However, the incident highlights internal debates within Saudi Arabia as it navigates a delicate balance between maintaining ties with the U.S. and addressing domestic and regional Arab sentiment toward Palestine.

International Reactions

  • Israel: Netanyahu’s office dismissed the remarks as “absurd and offensive,” reaffirming Israel’s sovereignty over its current territory. Far-right ministers seized on the comments to accuse Saudi Arabia of “incitement.”
  • United States: The State Department declined to comment directly but reiterated its support for a negotiated two-state solution. Trump, however, called the proposal “an interesting concept” during a campaign rally, sparking further outrage.
  • Palestinian Authority: While avoiding direct endorsement, Palestinian officials welcomed the “attention to Palestinian suffering” but stressed that relocation rhetoric distracts from core issues of occupation and rights.

Historical Precedents and Practical Realities

Al-Saadoun’s proposal echoes historically controversial ideas, such as the early 20th-century “Uganda Scheme” (a British proposal to create a Jewish homeland in East Africa) and the Nazi-era “Madagascar Plan.” Modern international law, however, firmly rejects forced displacement of populations as a violation of human rights.

Geopolitically, relocating Israel—a nation of 9.4 million people—is logistically inconceivable. Alaska and Greenland, both sparsely populated, are territories of the U.S. and Denmark, respectively. Neither has indicated willingness to host such a project, which would require unprecedented global consensus.

Saudi-Israel Relations: A Complex Landscape

The incident comes amid ongoing normalization talks between Saudi Arabia and Israel, brokered by the U.S. While Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has signaled openness to diplomatic ties, Saudi leadership insists any deal must include irreversible steps toward Palestinian statehood.

Al-Saadoun’s remarks risk complicating these negotiations. Critics argue the Shura Council member’s rhetoric undermines Saudi Arabia’s image as a stabilizing regional force, while pro-Palestine advocates argue it reflects lingering public opposition to normalization without Palestinian justice.

Broader Implications

The controversy underscores several key issues:

  1. Freedom of Speech in Saudi Arabia: The fact that Al-Saadoun’s remarks leaked suggests evolving, though limited, transparency within Saudi governance.
  2. Arab Public Opinion: Despite official normalization efforts, grassroots Arab solidarity with Palestine remains strong, constraining leaders’ flexibility.
  3. U.S. Electoral Politics: Trump’s flirtation with the idea highlights how Middle East policies may become entangled in America’s 2024 election cycle.

Expert Analysis

Dr. Hana Al-Khalidi, a Riyadh-based political scientist, noted: “This is likely an isolated opinion, but it reveals the frustration many feel over the international community’s double standards. Relocating Israel isn’t a solution—it’s a metaphor for demanding accountability.”

Meanwhile, Israeli analyst David Levi responded: “Such statements only deepen mistrust. Peace requires recognizing realities on the ground, not fantastical proposals.”

What’s Next?

Saudi Arabia is expected to reaffirm its commitment to the Arab Peace Initiative in coming days. Al-Saadoun has not publicly clarified his remarks, and the Shura Council may issue a formal reprimand to quell backlash.

For now, the incident serves as a reminder of the explosive emotions underlying the Israeli-Palestinian conflict—and the risks of rhetorical escalation in a region already on edge.

You Might Also Like

Japan Urges Indonesia to Join Unified Effort in Persuading Trump to Reconsider Trade War Policies

Fire Incident at Kenya International Airport-A Report

Elon Musk at CPAC: A Symbolic Appearance with a Chainsaw

The Dismissal of a German Judge Amidst Electoral Data Disputes

The Health Condition of Pope Francis: A Necessitated Prolongation of Medical Care Due to Double Pneumonia

Andy February 11, 2025 February 10, 2025
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Iceland in 2025 – The World’s Safest Country to Visit
Next Article The Tragic Mid-Air Disintegration Over the Waters of China Airlines Flight 611
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending Stock

HOT NEWS

Lando Norris is optimistic about Winning the F1 World Championship in 2025

Sports
5 months ago

United States, Australia, and South Korea Unite to Ban China’s DeepSeek AI Technology

In a landmark decision, the United States, Australia, and South Korea have announced a coordinated…

332.3k Views

Trump Deports 104 Indian Immigrants Using C-17 Military Aircraft

In a highly controversial move, U.S. President Donald Trump oversaw the deportation of 104 undocumented…

332.7k Views

BYD Sealion 07 With A Blend of Innovation and Striking Design

The electric vehicle (EV) market is evolving rapidly, with manufacturers pushing the boundaries of technology…

536.7k Views

Top Stories

Erdogan to Visit Indonesia Next Week for a High-Level Meeting with President Prabowo

Politics 432.7k Views

YR24, Astronomers Discover Massive Asteroid with Potential Earth Impact Threat

World 524.8k Views

UEFA Champions League 2024-2025: Clubs that Qualified and Missed Out on the Knockout Stage

Sports 325.7k Views

Zelensky: Ukraine Excluded from Peace Talks by US and Russia

Politics 172.4k Views

Recent Posts

  • Bank Indonesia Responds to Google’s Display of a 50% Strengthening of the Rupiah

    Bank Indonesia Responds to Google’s Display of a 50% Strengthening of the Rupiah

    In a surprising turn of events that has stirred both …
  • Trump Signs Executive Order Promoting Crypto

    Trump Signs Executive Order Promoting Crypto

    In January 2025, former President Donald Trump signed an executive …
  • Malware “Tria Stealer” Poses Serious Threat to Android Users

    Malware “Tria Stealer” Poses Serious Threat to Android Users

    A new malware variant known as “Tria Stealer” is emerging …
  • Trump sends an envoy to Panama to discuss the United States desire to control the Panama Canal

    Trump sends an envoy to Panama to discuss the United States desire to control the Panama Canal

    In recent developments that reflect the ongoing geopolitical maneuverings of …
  • Sayonara Shin Tae-Yong,  Welcome Patrick Kluivert

    Sayonara Shin Tae-Yong, Welcome Patrick Kluivert

                      Recently, …
We are a trusted media source to get information, news, and articles related to the business world.

All the latest news articles straight to your screen

Address: 2 Chome-9-7 Sugamo, Toshima City, Tokyo 170-0008, Japan
Phone: +81 3-5961-0712
Email: customercare@pelapakmobil.com
Our website stores cookies on your computer. They allow us to remember you and help personalize your experience with our site..

Read our privacy policy for more information.

Copyright © 2019-2025 PelapakMobil.com, All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?